NEWS
& POLITICS: August 27

A sleepless summer night in Bryant Park

by Harry Swartz-Turfle
Bryant Park is usually a peaceful ivy-carpeted oasis from the bustle
of midtown Manhattan. Weekday evenings the suit-and-tie crowd goes
home, leaving the surrounding skyscrapers distant and candlelit
when I walk home from work at dusk. The olive limbs of the park's
tall elm trees meander up to provide a thin canopy from the monstrous
modernism of the office towers and the inspired neo-classical library
building. But last night more than the usual bums sprawled out on
the benches. Campaign activist bums had set up an impromptu shanty-town
of laptops and mocha to promote the people's candidate, Howard Dean.
A woman leafleting on Sixth Avenue hawked her flyers by saying
"Come to the concert tonight." And on Dean's campaign
speaker equipment was stenciled "TAKE BACK AMERICA" in
the same way equipment might say "MONSTERS OF ROCK." On
stage, graffiti writers on ladders wrote tags like "Hi Mom"
and "CHiNO" while a DJ spun trance music. An MC had the
audience yell "I am Dean for America," pumping up the
crowd by saying "C'mon New York -- Chicago did better than
that!" All this was to prepare the stage for Dean to talk about
balancing the budget and taking care of children's health. If George
W. Bush's talent is to make radical conservatism seem innocuously
normal, Democratic hopeful Howard Dean's is just the opposite: to
make normal, nuanced views seem radical.
"Just watch," Dan Torres said to me last night in Bryant
Park before Howard Dean breezed into town on his "Sleepless
Summer" tour. Torres, a 34-year-old IT consultant, had a "Dean
for America" poster propped on top of his baby's stroller while
the little tyke napped inside. A lifelong Democrat, Torres described
first seeing Dean on "Meet the Press." "When I saw
his passion and anger I thought I was looking into a mirror. Finally
-- a man who gets it."
Does Dean get it? In April I was surprised when the former Vermont
Governor spoke at the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Center
in the West Village. What impressed me then was how moderately Dean
spoke. Dean kept regressing to position himself in the center, even
when he had the chance to pander to a crowd of queers obviously
impressed by Vermont's Civil Union law. But instead of puffing himself
up, he declared that marriage is a complicated institution, that
he didn't know about gay marriage, but that Civil Unions were the
"right thing to do." Then he talked about how he supports
the second amendment because "When you say 'gun control' in
New York, they think it's taking away Uzis on the street. When you
say 'gun control' in Wyoming, it means they're going to take away
the squirrel rifle that your grandfather gave you." Such is
Dean's contrarian way of speaking -- to always try an audience's
unqualified enthusiasm.
The "Sleepless Summer" folks trotted out a bunch of Dean
supporters before their candidate came out. "Hedwig and the
Angry Inch" star Anthony Rapp belted out "Seasons of Love,"
which the cast of "Rent" sang at the 1996 Democratic Convention.
Right then and there I began to doubt any affiliation I have had
with the party.
The one thing everyone agreed on last night was George W. Bush.
He's a liar, Dean's supporters said. He should be impeached. He's
bankrupted the country. He's feeding his fat-cat friends with juicy
government contracts. "They're running the tax books like Ken
Lay did," one Dean supporter said of the President. I asked
a 29-year-old attorney from Queens why he is interested in Dean's
candidacy. "Because he's the most blunt in attacking Bush."
A recent retiree came to the rally because he wants to find "somebody
who can beat Bush." A middle-aged man said "Bush is a
creature of corporate and special interests."
By this point, the line at Ben & Jerry's was much longer than
the one for Starbucks. And there was no one in line for Mister Softee.
Ground Zero Congressman Jerry Nadler came out swinging and showed
he's no lightweight. "Bush has deliberately misled the American
people on life and death issues
we in New York especially
need Howard Dean."
Congressman Major Owens from Prospect Heights tried pumping up
the crowd. "My constituents in Brooklyn need Howard Dean. All
of New York needs Howard Dean. All of America needs Howard Dean."
The crowd went nuts when Owens yelled "Stop the war!"
And then came Alex Munoz. I don't know how a recent college graduate
gets to share the stage with a presidential candidate, but someone's
got to give this kid a contract. Munoz screamed into the mic like
a drunk football coach at a karaoke bar, except Munoz is a Republican
Special Forces recruit who just graduated Columbia University --
and a Dean supporter. He took the mic like Naz and dropped poetry:
"We must reclaim our role as an inspired moral force."
It was a tough act for Lowell Weicker to follow. The former Senator
and Governor of Connecticut said "The present king has no clothes,
and Howard Dean is the only man who has the guts to say it
.
He speaks the truth about reality in America. And the reality is
a failed foreign policy."
"I don't think [Dean] has a realistic view of the world,"
said Miriam Gloger, a 25-year-old library employee and joint Israeli-American
citizen. Howard Dean's reality is the perception that he's either
too inexperienced and idealistic in foreign policy. Though the Texas
governorship gave George W. Bush experience dealing with Mexico,
Dean's position in Vermont doesn't quite compare, even though dealing
with French-speaking Quebec is enough to make one yearn for simpler,
pre-NAFTA days. Walking past the Dean group, Gloger wondered aloud,
"Are they serious about foreign affairs?" And then she
said that she, Rudy Giuliani, and Henry Kissinger are the only three
Republicans left in New York.
When Dean finally came out to speak, C-SPAN's cameras were primed.
The crowd was in the thousands. One group held up a sign that said
"CT for Dean." Another group had t-shirts that said "Philadelphia
loves Dean." With Dean's support growing, and whispers that
he's watered down his platform, I wondered whether Dr. Dean would
change his message from five months earlier, when he had no money
and very few supporters. Dean's message from then to now is as even
as an EKG: "we need a new President."
Dean would mention an issue and plant one foot on either side,
not in a sleazy culpable deniability way, but in a stubborn Yankee
way. One minute he'd say "When it comes to defense, as they
say in Texas this President's all hat and no cattle." Then
he would decry the war in Iraq. And then he would say he supported
the first Gulf War and the war in Afghanistan. Or he'd mention how
he wants to create jobs through small business, but then say that
small businesses pay less and frequently don't offer benefits. Did
Bill Clinton ever admit that he was creating low-paying jobs? Does
George W. Bush ever admit to destroying jobs?
Dean's become more polished since the GLBT center in April. His
voice was hoarse then, his clothes very rumpled, and his talking
more unpolished. His cell phone went off during his speech, and
sometimes he had to verbally retrace his speech. But last night
he didn't miss a beat when he said "I will restore the honesty,
dignity and respect that this country deserves."
After the speech, I asked what people thought. "Pretty strong,"
said Dave, a New Yorker in his forties who lives in Montreal. "But
I thought he'd be a little stronger." Some people were enthusiastic
about what they saw. One man claimed "This is the first time
I've considered voting for someone and not just against. Though
it's both really." One Democrat referred to the election between
Democrat mayoral candidate Mark Green and Michael Bloomberg: "I
hope this turns out better."
About
Harry Swartz-Turfle
Harry thinks Bryant Park should keep its
program of using hawks to keep pigeons and rodents away.
Talk about Howard Dean at the The Water Cooler
|