ARTS
& MEDIA: December 29

Exterminate all rational thought: Naked
Lunch on DVD

by Jason Minnix

Coming off the critical success of "Dead Ringers" (1988),
David Cronenberg found himself in an enviable position. At a creative
peak, the director was finally able to tackle head-on the most famous
work of literature by a writer who had been a major influence since
the very beginning of his career.
Cronenberg said that a literal film adaptation of William S, Burroughs's
1959 novel "Naked Lunch" would cost hundreds of millions
of dollars and be banned across the globe. In his early attempts
at writing, Cronenberg had fought to find his own voice among the
heavy influences of Burroughs and his other literary touchstone,
Vladimir Nabokov. Now, he essentially had to do the opposite. Having
reached a new level of confidence in his own work, he had to develop
a fusion of his own sensibility with that of Burroughs. The resulting
film is an amalgam of Cronenberg and Burroughs, not only "Naked
Lunch," but other novels and elements of the writer's life
as well.
In 1953 in New York City, junkie Bill Lee (Peter Weller) works
as an exterminator, or at least he tries to; his wife Joan (Judy
Davis) has taken to pilfering his bug powder, shooting it up in
search of a new buzz (prompting Davis's now-classic line, "It's
a very literary high. It's a Kafka high. It makes you feel like
a bug."). Lee is also a writer, although as he tells his close
friends, the Ginsberg and Kerouac surrogates Martin (Michael Zelniker)
and Hank (Nicholas Campbell), he is ready to give up the game as
too dangerous.
Taken in by police for interrogation regarding his missing bug
powder, he is confronted by the largest bug he has ever seen: a
giant cockroach-like creature that speaks to Lee though a very human-like
asshole in its back. The bug tells Lee that Joan is a secret agent,
not to be trusted, and may not be human at all. Lee is ordered to
kill Joan. "And it must be done real tasty."
Lee is directed by a fellow exterminator to see Dr. Benway (Roy
Schneider) under the pretense of kicking his and his wife's bug
powder addiction, though he may also be looking to score some additional
powder. Benway gives him a new drug to cut the bug powder with,
the black meat of the aquatic Brazilian centipede. Later, after
injecting himself with some of the black meat, Lee suggests to Joan
that they do their "William Tell routine." In a scene
taken from Burroughs's own life, she places a glass on her head,
and in his attempt to shoot it off, Lee kills his wife. Unable to
deal with the consequences of what he has done (and at the urging
of yet another creature, the vaguely reptilian mugwump), Lee flees
New York for the Tangiers-like Interzone. Once there, he must contend
with not only his own spiraling drug use, but incessant paranoia
regarding those he meets, including drug dealer Hans (Cronenberg
regular Robert A. Silverman), Paul and Jane Bowles-inspired Tom
and Joan Frost (Ian Holm and Davis again), and the hovering presence
of an unseen Dr. Benway.
Near the beginning of the film, Bill Lee says, "Exterminate
all rational thought." Viewers might do well to follow his
advice. Cronenberg's most brilliant decision in his witty script
is to present Lee's hallucinations as physical. A typewriter may
change from a mechanical object, to a typewriter-bug hybrid, to
a bag of pharmaceuticals, and back again, but because the events
are experienced by the audience along with Lee (only on a couple
of occasions is he not present in the scene), the metaphorical associations
remain clear. The film does not operate on a level of what is real
and what is not. Even though at its heart a drama about the creative
process, the film presents the various creatures and events as not
pure hallucination, allowing it to work on a fantastic level as
well. Lee is the audience surrogate of sorts since we experience
the events of the film with him. He may at first register slight
disbelief at what is in front of him (these reactions provide a
fair amount of the film's humor), but he is quick to accept what
he sees, and so are we.
Still, every indication is given that Lee never even leaves New
York. (Burroughs himself did run off to Tangiers for a while after
shooting his wife.) The character of Kiki is first encountered in
a New York bar, then again in Interzone; Lee comments that the Frosts'
apartment strongly resembles a restaurant he knows in New York;
when Martin and Hank visit to check up on Lee, his Interzone apartment
looks much like his New York place.
Because Lee's experiences are all presented subjectively, "Naked
Lunch" can become an almost oppressive journey for the viewer.
At times, the film does feel (necessarily) like a bad trip. By the
time Dr. Benway makes a return appearance at the end of the film,
some viewers may feel as if their brains have come close to collapsing.
The means of his reappearance certainly makes for one of the most
transgressive moments in the Cronenberg canon.
The cast members are all keyed into the proceedings and understand
their roles well. Weller certainly has the toughest job, and his
performance is exceptional. His performance and appearance manage
to evoke Burroughs without falling into simple impersonation. He
conveys both the film's sadness and humor very well. His recitation
of the "talking asshole" routine in the film rivals Burroughs's
own.
After her work in 1991's other great tortured writer film ("Barton
Fink"), Judy Davis has a great time as Joan Lee, finding the
humor in her junkie role while refusing to ham it up. Her Joan Frost
provides her with the other end of the spectrum: calm, reserved,
neatly dressed, though she does let herself go when combining black
centipede meat and an Arabic typewriter.
Ian Holm provides great intelligence for Tom Frost, a writer who
has been around the block, but who manages to keep his creativity
in check in a way Bill Lee cannot.
Roy Schnieder has relatively little screen time, but gives Benway
a level of sinister calculation behind his friendly façade.
As usual for a Cronenberg production, technical aspects from his
regular collaborators are top notch. Carol Spier's production design
is rich and full exotic detail. When Iraq War I forced the production
to scrap location work in Tangiers, everything had to be built from
scratch, and Spier's work is amazing. Peter Suschitsky's photography
ranks with his best for the director, working wonders with shadows
that truly do enhance the characters rather than simply color them.
Howard Shore's score, performed by the London Philharmonic and supplemented
by Ornette Coleman, fuses jazz, Middle Eastern sounds, and his own
familiar minor key orchestral work into a cohesive whole.
Criterion's DVD is unsurprisingly an outstanding presentation of
not only the film itself but also of its attendant extras. The movie
itself is presented on disc one in a 1.78 ratio in a director-supervised
transfer; the film looks practically three-dimensional, providing
a wonderful sense of physical depth to the film. Sound is the original
two-channel stereo track, clean, clear, and untampered-with, except
for the usual clean-up process.
Disc one also features a commentary track featuring Cronenberg
and Weller (recorded separately and edited together). This is Cronenberg's
fifth track (after "Dead Ringers," "eXistenZ,"
"Spider," and the laserdisc of "Crash"), and
he does his usual excellent job, discussing influences (such as
the Saul Bass-inspired opening credits), what he tried to achieve
creatively, his relationship with Burroughs, and technical aspects
of the production. He is not shy to mention that he finds the special
effects lacking in a key sequence late in the film, and also points
out his own sort-of cameo. Weller gets much less time on the track,
but speaks fondly of his collaborators and also of the fact that
filming "Naked Lunch" helped him through a very difficult
time in his life.
Disc two contains the remainder of the supplements. Chris Rodley's
"South Bank Show" documentary "Naked Making Lunch"
provides a thorough (for its 48 minute running time) account of
how Burroughs's book eventually found its way to film some thirty
years after publication. Cronenberg, Burroughs, producer Jeremy
Thomas, and most of the major cast are interviewed. Particularly
intriguing of all are storyboards from an abandoned attempt by Anthony
Balch and Brion Gysin to film the novel in the sixties.
An extensive gallery of special effects designs is provided, as
are promotional photos of the cast and the production. The film's
superb theatrical trailer is included, as well as two shorter TV
spots. A few minutes of on-set b-roll footage is included, as is
the six-minute electronic press kit featurette. Excerpts from a
1995 audio book of Burroughs reading his book and a photo gallery
from the collection of Allen Ginsberg round out the disc.
The nicely designed booklet reprints Janet Maslin's New York Times
review and essays by Gary Indiana, Chris Rodley, and Burroughs that
originally appeared in. "Everything is Permitted: the Making
of 'Naked Lunch,'" a book certainly worth picking up for fans
of Cronenberg's film.
About
Jason Minnix
Jason Minnix lives in Ithaca, New York,
with his wife Sheryl and his ridiculously-large DVD collection.
Talk movies at the The Water Cooler
|